Hear me out on this I'm considering getting a 2004 Ford Explorer xlt or a 2005 jetta 2.5?

The Jetta gets 22 city 30 Highway. Tank capacity 14.5 gallons which means 319 miles city 435 highway while on the other hand the explorer gets 16 city and 21 highway with a fuel tank capacity of 22.5 gallons which would mean city it'll get 360 city 472 highway wouldn't the explorer get the better gas mileage? But yes it is more expensive to fill Jetta would cost around 34 dollars and the explorer around 54 dollars

Read more: Hear me out on this I'm considering getting a 2004 Ford Explorer xlt or a 2005 jetta 2.5?